By Ross Cohen
•
September 16, 2025
The rise of artificial intelligence has forever changed how people search for information and connect with brands online. One of the most talked-about innovations is ChatGPT—a conversational AI that generates detailed, contextual, and remarkably human-like responses. As businesses and marketers race to adapt to this new landscape, an urgent question dominates industry forums: Can ChatGPT rank websites? This question isn’t just technical; it strikes at the heart of how marketers, entrepreneurs, and agencies like GetPhound will approach digital growth in the coming years. In this blog post, explore the difference between traditional search engine rankings and how AI models like ChatGPT “surface” websites and content in their responses. Learn why the conversation around ranking is more nuanced than ever, what factors influence whether AI mentions your brand, and discover actionable strategies—rooted in Generative Engine Optimization (GEO)—to ensure your website remains visible and influential in an AI-first world. What Does It Mean to “Rank” a Website? When most people think about website ranking, they picture the familiar Google search results page: a hierarchy of blue links ordered by relevance, authority, and other factors. Traditional SEO (“Search Engine Optimization”) involves technical tweaks, keyword integration, link-building campaigns, and on-page optimizations—all with the aim of climbing up those ranked results. ChatGPT, on the other hand, doesn’t return a list of links ranked by an algorithm. Instead, it provides synthesized answers—sometimes with a few “recommended resources” or mentions—based on its training data and conversational context. That means “ranking” in ChatGPT is not deterministic or transparent: the criteria are broader, the process more opaque. Instead of battling for “spot #1,” websites compete for inclusion in AI-generated responses, where authority and relevance often matter more than technical SEO factors. So, for businesses and marketers trying to optimize for this new environment, ranking is about becoming one of the sources most likely to be surfaced by conversational AI during relevant queries, rather than achieving a defined numbered position in a results list. How ChatGPT Chooses What to Show While Google actively indexes and ranks web pages in real time, ChatGPT works differently. Its core mechanism is grounded in: Training data: ChatGPT’s recommendations are based on the massive volume of web pages, books, wiki articles, and more it was trained on, up to its latest update. It does not “crawl the web” live. Pattern recognition: When asked a question, ChatGPT predicts the most useful answer by detecting patterns from its training—matching user prompts to relevant language and knowledge. Perceived authority: Well-established, authoritative websites, frequently referenced in reputable sources, are more likely to inform ChatGPT’s answers. Factors ChatGPT weighs include: Mentions across the web (brand and product references) Content clarity and structure (headings, bullet points, FAQs) Domain age and online reputation The relevance and topical depth of content Because ChatGPT acts like a highly knowledgeable guide, “ranking” is more about convincing the AI that your website is a trusted resource worth mentioning or paraphrasing in a given context, rather than just fitting a set of SEO rules. How is This Different from Google or Bing Rankings? Traditional search engines rely on: Crawling and real-time indexing Evaluating hundreds of ranking factors—including backlinks, load speed, keyword placement, page structure, and user engagement metrics Outputting a live, continually updated SERP (Search Engine Results Page) ChatGPT and similar tools: Work with a static knowledge set, updated periodically but not live Focus on holistic authority, content trustworthiness, and frequent mentions in credible sources, rather than just technical on-page signals Surface answers, not a “top 10” list of direct links While Google’s algorithms can be targeted with technical fixes, ChatGPT optimization (“GEO” or Generative Engine Optimization) focuses on broadening your presence and authority across the internet, being referenced by authoritative sources, and ensuring your content is well-structured and up-to-date. The Rise of Generative Engine Optimization (GEO) With AI chat platforms grabbing a larger share of search intent—especially for top-of-funnel (TOFU) queries—marketers have coined the term “Generative Engine Optimization” (GEO). Unlike traditional SEO, which targets specific keyword rankings and search pages, GEO is about making your content so trusted, informative, and widely cited that conversational AIs like ChatGPT regularly reference your website in their answers. Key strategies for GEO include: Encouraging third-party sites (blogs, news outlets, review platforms) to mention or recommend your business Structuring your content for easy digestion by both readers and machines (clear headings, schema markup, FAQ sections) Keeping content up-to-date and aligned with trending industry topics Ensuring consistency in business data (like NAP: Name, Address, Phone) across the web As AI-driven answers become the norm—often at the expense of direct website visits—adapting to GEO is increasingly essential for sustained online visibility and business growth. The Role of Authority, Mentions, and Reviews The more frequently ChatGPT “sees” your brand and website referenced in trustworthy sources online, the higher the chance it will become part of its answer fabric. Authority is built over time. Critical factors: Brand Mentions: Articles, forums, and third-party sites mentioning your business—even without backlinks—contribute to perceived authority. Positive Reviews: Customer feedback on platforms like Google, Yelp, BBB, and industry review sites increases trustworthiness and likelihood of AI recommendation. Recommendations by Reputable Sources: When respected publications cite your products or insights, ChatGPT is more likely to paraphrase or mention your content. Content Age and Consistency: Older, consistently updated brands are considered more stable and thus more reliable sources. Social Signaling: Widespread recognition (high follower counts, customer testimonials, industry awards) signals your business is a pillar in its niche. For brands aiming to influence ChatGPT answers, the focus shifts from gaming algorithms to building genuine, long-term authority and trust across the internet. Content Structure & Clarity—Why It Matters AI language models digest information more effectively from well-structured, clearly written content. ChatGPT “prefers” content that: Uses distinct headings and subheadings (H1, H2, etc.) Contains bullet points, tables, and concise paragraphs Is easy for both humans and machines to parse for relevant details Best practices: Break up long blocks of text with descriptive headers Use schema markup to highlight FAQs, reviews, products, or local business data Write clear, jargon-free copy, but supply technical depth where necessary Include summary sections and actionable takeaways Not only does this improve user experience, but it also makes it easier for AI to “extract” and accurately summarize your insights when generating answers—further enhancing your brand’s inclusion in relevant responses. The Impact of Semantic Search Traditional keyword tactics matter less in the age of AI. Instead, semantic search—how closely your content’s meaning aligns with various ways users phrase their questions—takes center stage. ChatGPT and other LLMs (Large Language Models) interpret intent, context, and nuanced phrasing. This means: Pages built solely to target exact-match keywords may be less effective Comprehensive coverage of a topic and connected subtopics is key Semantic SEO strategies—building clusters of in-depth, interrelated content—better align with how AI decides what to surface For businesses, this means mapping out all the facets of a customer’s journey, creating rich resources that answer broad and niche queries, and focusing on subject “authority” clusters, rather than over-optimizing individual pages around narrow terms. The Limits of ChatGPT’s “Ranking” Power While the idea of optimizing directly for AI-driven answers is exciting, there are several important limits to keep in mind: Staleness of Data: ChatGPT’s knowledge is not live. If your website was created or updated after its last training cut-off, those changes may not be reflected for months. Lack of Transparent Ranking Mechanics: ChatGPT’s response generation is opaque; there’s no public “algorithm” for inclusion and no clear ranking position, only a likelihood of being referenced. Linkless Awareness: Sometimes, ChatGPT will summarize your insights or products without directly linking or naming you, making attribution and measuring success challenging. In other words, optimizing for ChatGPT is more about building brand and resource visibility across the whole of the internet, rather than targeting a single AI’s backend. ChatGPT and Google—Friends or Foes for SEO? The relationship between ChatGPT and Google is evolving rapidly. While Google remains the world’s dominant search engine, the line is blurring: Google’s AI Integration: Google now surfaces AI-generated answers (AI Mode, Gemini summaries) alongside traditional SERPs. User Behavior Shift: As more consumers use tools like ChatGPT for fast, direct answers—especially TOFU, research, and comparison queries—traditional search and website traffic patterns are changing. No AI Penalty (Yet): Google has stated that AI-generated content is not penalized, as long as it is high-quality, original, and meets guidelines such as E-E-A-T (Experience, Expertise, Authoritativeness, and Trustworthiness). Lost Visibility Risk: If customers get answers from AI chats rather than web links, websites optimized exclusively for Google risk being overlooked altogether. Forward-thinking brands adopt a hybrid approach—continuing technical SEO while also investing in broader brand-building and GEO for AI platform mention and paraphrase. Actionable Steps—How to Make Your Website AI-Ready For businesses and agencies like GetPhound, here’s a checklist to maximize the odds of being surfaced by ChatGPT and other conversational AI platforms: Grow Brand Mentions: Outreach to journalists, guest posting, getting listed in “best of” guides, and encouraging industry partners to talk about your brand increases AI visibility. Maximize Review Signals: Solicit reviews on high-credibility review sites. Respond to feedback, and ensure profiles are fully filled out. Structured Content: Use comprehensive, well-organized resources—such as guides, hub pages, FAQ blocks, and glossaries. Schema Markup Implementation: Add appropriate structured data to clarify your authority and business details for AI parsing. Consistent NAP Data: Ensure business Name, Address, Phone, and other identifiers are uniform everywhere, a cornerstone of local and AI-driven optimization. Hyper-Local and Topical Depth: Provide expert, up-to-date, and deeply detailed content in your specialty. Cover topics widely and regularly update posts. GEO Roadmap: Implement Generative Engine Optimization as a parallel discipline to technical SEO, balancing both for maximum reach in an AI-first discovery world. Remember, as ChatGPT and similar models are increasingly integrated into traditional search experiences, the brands that proactively optimize for AI-driven mention and recommendation will secure a powerful advantage as industry paradigms shift. Overall The question “Can ChatGPT rank websites?” reflects a pivotal moment in digital marketing. While ChatGPT doesn’t “rank” in the traditional sense, it absolutely does influence which brands and resources millions of people encounter when seeking information, making mastery of AI-driven visibility essential for long-term growth. For businesses and agencies like GetPhound, success is now about more than checking technical SEO boxes—it’s about building genuine authority, fostering broad mention and citation, and structuring content for both people and intelligent machines. By blending Generative Engine Optimization with classic SEO, staying transparent, and always focusing on delivering real value, brands can remain discoverable, trusted, and influential—no matter how technology or search evolves.